The Old Man in the Piazza - Salman Rushdie


I've been thinking about this story a lot since I read it, but I'm not quite sure I get it.

At first I thought it was going to be a simple-ish allegory about the current state of the U.S., about how we can't get along, and I was hoping that it would end with an answer, or at least a recommendation. Instead, it ends with a warning. We have wasted our words, the gift of language, the one thing that separates us from the animals (according to some). We have misused it until it ceased to serve any purpose and we lost it. 

But what is he really getting at here? There's that whole part about the "Era of Yes," or whatever he called it, when everyone was forced to get along, and Language, in the corner, seemed unhappy about that. Then when that era ended, and everyone started arguing again, Language was again the object of attention (mostly from the young), but was she any happier? Or is she simply just there - sometimes noticed, sometimes not? 

So it seems he didn't think the Era of Yes was especially good for language, but then he didn't make the argument era out to sound all that great either. (But some of the early descriptions of the things that people argued over was amusing.) It seemed to be the judgement era that eventually pushed Language out of the Piazza. Is it anti-judgement? Is it anti-wanting-to-let-some-random-authority-be-the-final-arbiter? Is it anti-mass-brainwashing?

It still seems to me that it's got to be an allegory about something ... but I don't know exactly what.

TAL

Comments

  1. I suppose essay questions might be:
    What does the old man represent?
    What drives 'Language' out of the square? Is she upset? Does she feel she has no purpose anymore?
    Why does the Old Man agree to act as Judge?
    Why do the people want such a judge?

    I want answers!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment